Tuesday, August 20, 2013

August '13 Editorial for Prabhu Tarun: "In Search Of The 'Reset Button!"

'Faith' and 'blind faith' are two very strong words that come out of the same emotion, the same word but can have diverse effects on us because they are either a result of a combination of experiences or a higher degree of unconditional emotions or merely a trust in hearsay or myths! We interact with people in our lives and with various positive or negative experiences we start trusting these very people with wide levels of affection - we develop what we call 'faith' in people. Everyday we stand in front of the Almighty thank him for what he has given us and very often ask for some blessing in the form of health, wealth or well being and when we get it from Him it strengthens our 'faith' in Him sometimes converting it into blind faith! There are certain people in whom we implicitly trust because they have proven their unconditional love and affection towards us in action and words. We then reciprocate similarly to those feelings and thus blossoms a relationship which keeps building on mutual trust, faith and love. When there is such a background to any relationship 'faith' becomes an integral aspect of that relation and slowly at times graduates towards blind faith. But what happens to that trust we instil in age old beliefs, customs, and superstitions which arise out of just hearsay or mere age old practices? So is this termed as blind faith as well? or a better term could be 'myth faith' So we humans start having faith in myths which are age old superstitions and practices and which today hold no scientific relevance. Well this myth faith does arise out of teachings passed on from those people on whom we have had immense trust and faith. But have we ever asked the question why before we follow some of these age old superstitions? Very often customs and traditions are connected with auspicious occasions like weddings and festivals. These customs and traditions help us bond with our people, they strengthen our value system, they help keep our respective community together because they distinguish us from the rest of the people who follow their own sets of traditions. In totality these traditions encourage positivity and spread happiness during those times of the year when we are all looking forward to sharing some memorable moments with the people we love and care. So one may ask why question such wonderful practices! To which I completely agree! I am absolutely in favour of practicing such traditions which help and encourage us to bond and further enhance our relations. But there are a few superstitions which we Indians follow in the name of customs and traditions which are probably just myths! Myths that spread negativity and gloom. A myth that generates fear - a black cat crossing our path is inauspicious! Many of us know that it's a myth but a lot of us still hold ourselves back if a black cat does cross our path and especially if we probably are on our way for an interview. If biologically the poor cat has inherited that colour, and happens to take the same route as us, how can there be a scientific justification of this incident being a bad omen? Cutting nails or hair post sunset or sweeping the house after sunset is termed inauspicious. Well most often we never sweep at night but if there is a one off day when we have to then will that day be a dooms day just because we swept the floor? How can a hygienic practice of cutting nails be a bad omen irrespective of the time? Do the nails have any sensors that indicate the time of the day? A whining dog, a twitching eye, a cowing crow, sighting an owl, sighting an elephant, itching palms! So many good and bad omens which we still hear people follow! The probability of these instances occurring often is low, and the after effects of both following or not following these myths may be very inconspicuous. But some of the myths play a very harsh role in our lives and are actually a stigma for many! A widow is considered inauspicious, she needs to step down on her efforts to look attractive. A woman who cannot give birth is inauspicious! No amount of justification can ever prove this a fact! And women can only change this for themselves by believing that they have every right to live a full life. I used to think that in our well educated and forward thinking society such myths no longer exist, but we women are responsible for allowing them to still dwell in our lives. Even today it is the other women in the house who compel some less fortunate women to follow these sick age old myths arising out of sheer lack of knowledge. While it is a myth that these myths don't exist in our society, there is one such myth which we all will agree that it sure prevails in many households even today! The famous menstrual taboo! A biological process which graduates a little lady into a mother and presents the family the most beautiful gift of tiny feet that bring in all the happiness and cheer into our homes is still considered a taboo even in educated homes today. I would like to know which God in mythology has verified this myth and asked us ladies to not greet Him when we are in one of those days! How many pickles rot, how much of the food we cook gets polluted and for how many people we are termed a bad omen in our 'those' days has never been verified or even backed up with scientific conclusions. But this taboo is so well ingrained in us that we have been happily allowing people around us to treat us as untouchables and probably we will pass on the same baton to our daughters in the future! That's the unfortunate truth of this real myth! I found a logical answer to why such a practice of isolating women during their periods began in the first place. I may be wrong, but in comparison to there being no firm logic for following this taboo, I prefer believing the below logic, which makes a lot of sense to me! If amongst our readers we get more such reasonable answers I will be more than happy to know. What I have been told is that, in older times we didn't have a hygienic solution such as a sanitary napkin to allow a clean way of dealing with periods. So the only solution was to keep the ladies away from the routine cooking and holy rituals. Also during menstruation ladies undergo hormonal changes and bleeding can cause weakness and pain. Just as a reason for ladies to get their much deserved rest during this time, isolation was considered a solution. But just as 'the Chinese whispers' this solution slowly converted into a taboo! Lot of ladies as well as men ask me why I get so furious on this particular issue, if I am not affected by it directly? Well I may not be, but then I know a lot of ladies around me who do have to face this on a regular basis and that affects a lot of people and activities involving them! Some unfortunately themselves believe that they sure are impure in those days and the isolation will help them sustain their equation with God! While some ladies, agree with me, but are helpless about it and prefer keeping silent than revolting. Some men think its none of their business and its too much of a ladies' problem to get them involved in. They think too much is made out of nothing and abstaining yourself from some activities in those days shouldn't make any difference! I wonder what would these men do if they were asked to abstain from the same activities without any logical reasoning! And of course! There are some men who say, if my mother can do it so can my sister and wife and so will my daughter! Now I have a problem with this mindset, where you are regressive yourself, and you continue making your next generation equally regressive until they grow up to find no logic in it and decide to rebel, IF AT ALL THEY REBEL! I am thankful to two ladies, my mother and grandmother who never allowed this wonderful biological wonder to be treated as a taboo. They informed us of its power and educated us on why the not so aware society treats this wonder as a bad omen. Today this so called taboo is being extensively researched upon and is used to cure various ailments using the stem cells generated from it. Finally science is proving the 'old wives' wrong! The sooner we start changing our outlook towards these myths the lesser number of people we will hurt. If God's fear is not allowing some of us to change our outlook, then we at least need to figure out what is His will? He says be compassionate towards others. By ill-treating women in the name of God and rituals we are in the process anyway defeating God's will of being courteous and compassionate towards others. Moreover these superstitions are making our society regressive. Where science and technology are cutting their own benchmarks and moving ahead, we are still hanging on to our petty and shameful beliefs. India will need a revolution to change these superstitions. We women need to press the 'reset button' in our brains first to agree to not ill treat anyone in the name of rituals. Only then will we impart the same information to our generation next. Our gen next is aware of their reset button they use it way too often than us! We need to find our own and stomp it as soon as we can!

7 comments:

  1. Totally agree with you. I do question almost each and every such myth. I was lucky to have Baba, Babasaheb and Laduj in my life, who've at various times cleared misconceptions about such notions.

    Upaas - any amount of it , will not please the Gods, it is more a way to develop self-control, self-restraint.

    Cutting nails after dark - was meant for the olden times, when there were no lights and ppal could gash their fingers in the dark, trying to cut nails.

    not sneezing under a door frame - well, villages have huge ceilings on either side of the door frame and the frame itself is small. So if you sneeze, there's risk to banging your head on the frame. doesn't apply in our times when doing the same under 7-8 feet high frames.

    black cat syndrome - could have been one strange instance which co-incided with a bad happenning and ended up being a myth since that one happenstance. can't blame the cat and his mind for sure.

    menstrual stuff - again, fully agree with you. if God made man and woman and doesn't distinguish between them, highly illogical that He distinguishes between a menstruating and non-menstruating woman. i guess, its the cleanliness factor, in olden times of 'phadke' bandhna (yikes !!!!) and not in the times of stayfree, whispers and so on ... hahahaha...


    for the matter the biggest of them all, which i'm not sure you had or perhaps covered in bits and pieces. - Even praying to God, isn't a must. If we believe God resides in everybody, just be good, do good to others and that takes care of itself. No point praying in front of God and having a shitty behavior towards others otherwise.

    all that said, i just have one comment about your article. its a tad too long. would suggest you to shorten it a little bit. the juicy portions are in the latter half of the doc and the first part, seems to take a bit tooo long to unfold and unwind the real topics. a reader might loose interest going through the whole doc.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The subject is interesting and hopefully should inspire many readers. I liked the way you positively present examples of customs and traditions on one side and later reflect upon the various myths. This gives the reader a perfect direction, that here you are not trying to reset the family traditions and values, but you are trying to throw light on some unfortunate blind faiths. Such myths change our way of life and continue to affect the daily lives of many people. Even today ‘Menstrual taboo’ is discussed & altered conveniently in many households. I consider myself fortunate that I didn’t have to face such situations due to Aie & Aji’s progressive thinking, and I continue to enjoy the same today. However, most of our society is still hanging on to these myths. I think our earlier generation never questioned these superstitions. As you rightly said, we need to press the reset button again and again with a positive approach and question such myths. Overall the article gradually develops interest, could be edited in certain areas which appear stretched. I feel that you should consider printing reactions to this article as well.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I fully second your views mayura..
    Our Indian rituals n religouspractices are all having a scientific reason behind it...but most of the people follow this without even knowing the true value if these practices. Over a period of time they have turned into superstitions..

    but there r some people who have taken advantage of this and the sensitive indian...and turned it into a dangerous supposition..
    They call it superstition...and many have used this to their advantage..
    Its good that u have made a good attempt to write on the topic..and touch a sensitive topic..Todays generation needs to understand the beauty of our Indian culture..and the many religions..you have dwelled upon a great topic...
    Keep it up

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Moya! Read your article today and found it very well written and definitely agree with your view point about most of the rituals followed blindly.My only point of contention is linking Menstruation and religion! Tho I agree with your view point ,at the same time one thing that comes to my mind is that I am no competent authority to pass any comments but can just say that our ancestors were also educated and literate and our community as such is very broad-minded compared to others and there must be something which History may tell us why such riutals were followed so without making a thorough research,we cannot question that .

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yes there were reasons to follow these practices 100 years back because the living conditions were such.. which is what I have been wanting to stress on that some beliefs and practices were relevant so many years back.. but with humans and living conditions progressing, these practices should have evolved which we indians due to our regressive nature and our fear towards change, we were unable to do much. Whatever the findings could be of a research, but when we ask the question WHY if we dont get an answer then what our mind doesnt believe in, we need not follow especially if it hurts sentiments and can be rather demeaning to anyone. Why dont we still believe in 'the untouchables' who were once a taboo in the so called educated society our ancestors lived in? why dont we still ill treat a widow if our ancestors did so? if we cant question our ancestors on the menstrual taboo, why did we question them on the others and showed how progressive we are in those areas? was it convenience? was it a personal experience? years back our ancestors didnt believe in educating women, but since many generations our community has produced educated ladies.. why did our community bring this change and failed to bring a change in their thinking towards menstruation? was it because it was linked to God, and the fear of God suddenly pulls us down???? I can write another article on this I have that many points to make... but I would reserve them for a time we personally meet and can discuss this then.... thank you so much for your feedback and please do continue opining on my articles...

    ReplyDelete
  6. another point which seems extremely important is that I have always noticed that education is not a benchmark to decide someone's broad or narrow minded approach....while it is suppose to broaden our horizons .... a lot of educated people in this society have practiced rather negative and narrow minded beliefs

    ReplyDelete